AI Insights and Innovations

Backlash Against Dartmouth Provost Over AI-Generated Articles

By AI Design Desk•Oct 16, 2026
Backlash Against Dartmouth Provost Over AI-Generated Articles

Dartmouth College is facing an internal crisis as Provost Santiago Schnell's admission of using tools in writing professional articles has ignited backlash from students and faculty. This controversy arises amidst the college's public advocacy for embracing artificial intelligence in higher . In August, Schnell published an editorial in The Washington Post advocating for universities to differentiate between student capabilities with and without AI assistance. However, revelations that he utilized AI to generate that very essay have led to calls for his termination.

An investigation by Semafor revealed that Schnell's editorial was one of ten guest essays labeled as at least 80 percent -generated by the AI detector Pangram. In his defense, Schnell stated, "I wrote this essay based on my own thinking. Then, I used ChatGPT to refine a few arguments, check for grammatical errors, and submit it to The Washington Post." However, Pangram classified his work as 100 percent AI-generated, raising questions about the authenticity of his contributions.

The Dartmouth student newspaper conducted its own analysis using Pangram, which indicated that 96 percent of Schnell's nine professional articles published this year were predominantly AI-written. This included his Washington Post essay and two academic papers in mathematics. The investigation also revealed that Schnell used AI to draft emails related to his communications with the newspaper.

Schnell defended his actions, asserting that while he views AI as an assistive tool, it does not replace his research, intellectual judgment, or authorship. He contended that the characterization of his Washington Post essay as entirely AI-written was inaccurate. Nonetheless, students and faculty argue that his actions contravene the college's honor code, which mandates that students disclose the use of generative AI in their coursework. A petition from Dartmouth's chapter of the American Association of University Professors demanded his removal, stating, "How do we ask our students and colleagues to follow the rules when the academic leader of Dartmouth is allowed to break them?"

Schnell's case is not isolated; a significant number of academic leaders reportedly use AI tools in their work. According to Inside Higher Ed’s 2026 Survey of College and University Chief Academic Officers, 65 percent of respondents indicated they use AI for drafting communications, while 71 percent utilize AI in their work at least weekly. Despite the growing acceptance of AI, experts have raised concerns about the reliability of AI detection software, which can yield false positives. This has led to lawsuits from accused students who have successfully challenged their universities' reliance on such tools.

Tensions Over AI's Role in Academia

The backlash against Schnell reflects broader tensions in academia regarding the integration of AI. Dartmouth President Sian Beilock recently emphasized the need for universities to embrace AI, warning that those who do not adapt risk becoming irrelevant. However, critics like Eli Moyse, a government major at Dartmouth, argue that the administration's focus on AI is excessive and detrimental to academic integrity.

In response to the controversy, Beilock announced the formation of an independent advisory committee to evaluate Schnell's use of AI against the standards of the publications to which he submitted his work. She acknowledged that the anger directed at Schnell highlights larger issues facing higher education as institutions strive to balance academic integrity with the pressure to incorporate AI into curricula.

Schnell has since expressed his understanding of the concerns surrounding his AI usage, stating in a recent editorial for The Dartmouth that he recognizes the importance of disclosing AI assistance in his public writing. He noted that he should be more attentive to the expectations set by publications regarding AI use.

Why It Matters

As the debate continues, education technology consultant Tawnya Means highlighted the need for clear distinctions between assistance and substitution when using AI in writing. She argued that while AI can play a role in the writing process, it should not automatically trigger disclosure obligations, similar to consulting a dictionary or discussing ideas with colleagues.

The ongoing discourse surrounding Schnell's case presents an opportunity for higher education to clarify the role of human capabilities in conjunction with AI, emphasizing the importance of discernment and understanding in the academic process.

Explore on Amazon
Designing with AI

Explore human-centred design and interfaces for AI products.

Perfect Selections
Start with the fundamentals

Accessible introductions to artificial intelligence and data.

Perfect Selections
Think clearly about data

Build statistical reasoning and a better understanding of evidence.

Perfect Selections

Human-selected Sponsor

Across our publications

In Other News

Latest stories from other publications.

Explore all publications (opens in a new tab)